WoW Insider is getting ready for BlizzCon!

Review: City of Ember



One of the most gorgeous-looking films I've seen this year is City of Ember, the Fox/Walden adaptation of Jeanne Duprau's young-adult fantasy novel about a post-apocalyptic underground city. Although the story is aimed at younger audiences, it's still enjoyable for grown-ups. The movie should be viewed on as large a screen as you can find, giving you the sense that you're this close to the fascinating and decaying city where the story is set.

The movie's prologue lays out the premise clearly. In the future, something goes haywire that causes the end of the world, but fortunately top U.S. scientists have created an underground city to keep a portion of mankind safe. The inhabitants will not be told about the Earth's past, so they won't be traumatized and will assume that their underground city is the only civilization. A box with instructions for returning to the Earth's surface will open in 200 years, which should be time enough for the Earth to be inhabitable again. However, over the course of time the box becomes lost, and after more than two centuries have passed, the city is starting to run out of resources and is falling apart.

As the city declines, two children in Ember, Lina Mayfleet (Saorise Ronan) and Doon Harrow (Harry Treadaway) have both come of age and start working for the city -- Lina as a messenger, and Doon in the pipeworks. Doon wanted to be an electrician and is dying to tinker with the city's enormous generator, so it will stop its increasingly long and frequent blackouts. The mayor of Ember (Bill Murray) organizes a task force but otherwise seems to do little. Lina and Doon's older acquaintances also seem uninterested, telling the young people not to concern themselves with larger matters. But they are determined to find out what's wrong with their city, which to their mind is the only place where humans live, and fix whatever they can.

The movie reminded me a little of Dark City (the theatrical version, not the director's cut), but less creepy and more appropriate for kids. Both movies are set in an artificial city, created by beings other than those who dwell in it, for purposes the residents do not yet understand. In addition, both films open with the story behind the city's creation, which is spelled out for us in detail, and the suspense is not in our discoveries but in those of the characters. I would have preferred the increased suspense in keeping the city's origins a mystery from us, but the straightforward telling gives the movie more of a fairytale quality and makes it more accessible to younger viewers.

Caroline Thompson's script gives us strong main characters and entertaining supporting characters, but is a little light on story (which is the same feeling I've had about other movies she's scripted, such as Corpse Bride and Edward Scissorhands). I felt like City of Ember ended at an ambiguous moment -- right at the point where I expected another half-hour of conflict and action. I realize the book ended at this point, and also that there are sequels to the novel, so perhaps this is meant to leave the door open for sequels to the movie as well. It did feel like there were some loose ends -- I expected something more sinister from certain characters than what was delivered, and some items that appeared important were never quite explained.

However, the slightness of the story is more than made up for by the compelling characters, especially Lina and Doon. Tim Robbins (who plays Doon's father), Bill Murray, Toby Jones, and especially Martin Landau as Doon's coworker, provide vivid and colorful support. Gil Kenan, who previously directed the animated Monster House, has brought us another film in which the setting is a type of character itself -- this time the city of Ember, with its failing generator of a heart, and its warm lights that are starting to flicker and fade.

City of Ember will surely remind audiences of another family-friendly movie this year about human survival in the future, Wall-E. It's odd that two films with such similar themes about the future of Earth would appear in the same year, but I can't tell you whether that's coincidence (as with the Capote/Infamous debacle) or some political sign of our times. No overt political message smacked me in the face during this film; instead, I was absorbed in the curious and fascinating city for an hour and a half, enough to want another half-hour of movie, and cheering on the main characters. It's a simple and lovely tale, perfect for a family outing.

Related Headlines

Reader Comments

(Page 1)
NEWS
Awards (990)
Box Office (722)
Casting (4442)
Celebrities and Controversy (2194)
Columns (322)
Contests (271)
Deals (3670)
Distribution (1220)
DIY/Filmmaking (2079)
Executive shifts (104)
Exhibition (803)
Fandom (6271)
Home Entertainment (1573)
Images (1052)
Lists (476)
Moviefone Feedback (6)
Movie Marketing (2859)
New Releases (2253)
Newsstand (5177)
NSFW (103)
Obits (334)
Oscar Watch (611)
Politics (895)
Polls (84)
Posters (291)
RumorMonger (2693)
Scripts (1934)
Site Announcements (293)
Stars in Rewind (96)
Tech Stuff (442)
Trailers and Clips (1338)
BOLDFACE NAMES
James Bond (239)
George Clooney (163)
Daniel Craig (99)
Tom Cruise (252)
Johnny Depp (184)
Peter Jackson (148)
Angelina Jolie (178)
Nicole Kidman (62)
George Lucas (211)
Michael Moore (74)
Brad Pitt (187)
Harry Potter (199)
Steven Spielberg (325)
Quentin Tarantino (179)
FEATURES
Movies We're Thankful For (5)
12 Days of Cinematicalmas (60)
400 Screens, 400 Blows (152)
After Image (40)
Best/Worst (38)
Bondcast (8)
Box Office Predictions (129)
Celebrities Gone Wild! (26)
Cinematical Indie (4314)
Cinematical Indie Chat (4)
Cinematical Seven (361)
Cinematical's SmartGossip! (49)
Coming Distractions (13)
Critical Thought (352)
DVD Reviews (245)
Eat My Shorts! (16)
Fan Made (32)
Fan Rant (117)
Festival Reports (1072)
Film Blog Group Hug (58)
Film Clips (39)
Friday Night Double Feature (40)
From Page to Screen (26)
From the Editor's Desk (69)
Geek Report (85)
Girls on Film (6)
Guilty Pleasures (29)
Holiday Movie Junk (23)
Hold the 'Fone (430)
Indie Seen (7)
Indie Spotlight (26)
Insert Caption (168)
Interviews (397)
Killer B's on DVD (80)
Monday Morning Poll (58)
Movie Games (4)
New in Theaters (346)
New on DVD (345)
Podcasts (134)
Retro Cinema (81)
Review Roundup (47)
The Scary Bits (17)
Scene Stealers (14)
Scenes We Love (71)
Seven Days of 007 (25)
Summer Movies (152)
Sundance Reviews 2009 (29)
The Geek Beat (79)
The (Mostly) Indie Film Calendar (39)
The Rocchi Review: Online Film Community Podcast (41)
The Write Stuff (26)
Theatrical Reviews (1950)
Trailer Trash (506)
Unscripted (41)
Vintage Image of the Day (140)
GENRES
Action (6095)
Animation (1199)
Classics (1151)
Comedy (5587)
Comic/Superhero/Geek (3141)
Documentary (1562)
Drama (6617)
Family Films (1379)
Foreign Language (1701)
Games and Game Movies (342)
Gay & Lesbian (258)
Horror (2692)
Independent (3562)
Music & Musicals (1052)
Noir (239)
Mystery & Suspense (1056)
Religious (131)
Remakes and Sequels (4464)
Romance (1477)
Sci-Fi & Fantasy (3867)
Shorts (301)
Sports (317)
Thrillers (2182)
War (381)
Western (112)
FESTIVALS
Oxford Film Festival (5)
AFI Dallas (48)
Austin (25)
Berlin (91)
Cannes (357)
Chicago (18)
CineVegas (21)
ComicCon (142)
Fantastic Fest (94)
Gen Art (14)
Los Angeles Film Festival (11)
New York (57)
Other Festivals (313)
Philadelphia Film Festival (13)
San Francisco International Film Festival (34)
Seattle (67)
ShoWest (6)
Slamdance (25)
Sundance (708)
SXSW (352)
Telluride (81)
Toronto International Film Festival (442)
Tribeca (289)
Venice Film Festival (15)
WonderCon (2)
Friday Night Double Feature (1)
DISTRIBUTORS
Roadside Attractions (8)
20th Century Fox (770)
Artisan (2)
Disney (662)
Dreamworks (339)
Fine Line (4)
Focus Features (174)
Fox Atomic (21)
Fox Searchlight (204)
HBO Films (36)
IFC (144)
Lionsgate Films (472)
Magnolia (142)
Miramax (92)
MGM (218)
New Line (417)
Newmarket (17)
New Yorker (6)
Picturehouse (16)
Paramount (714)
Paramount Vantage (51)
Paramount Vantage (16)
Paramount Classics (49)
Samuel Goldwyn Films (16)
Sony (630)
Sony Classics (174)
ThinkFilm (117)
United Artists (44)
Universal (802)
Warner Brothers (1223)
Warner Independent Pictures (98)
The Weinstein Co. (516)
Wellspring (6)

RESOURCES

RSS NEWSFEEDS

  • RSS News Feed
Powered by Blogsmith

Sponsored Links

Most Commented On (60 days)

Recent Comments

Other Weblogs Inc. Network blogs you might be interested in: